Is this advert belittling the work of designers?

South West Trains is running a new ad campaign that has rubbed some designers up the wrong way.

South West trains advert

Click the image to head to SW Trains twitter page to see the enlarged version

South West Trains has just released a new campaign, with the banner ad heading up its Twitter page. Reading, '1,400 extra car parking spaces (more helpful than changing the shade of all our trains),' designer Andy Hau found the advert to be belittling of designers.

He told us, "I understand that South West Trains want to talk about the improvements they've made to their service but that's no reason to belittle the service we provide as designers. Designers bring a lot of value through their work and to classify what we do as 'unimportant' is damaging, irresponsible and ignorant.

"In a world where $5 logos and off-the-peg design are becoming the norm, South West trains compounds the misbelief that designers and design are a frivolous commodity – an afterthought to make something a little bit more interesting. I'm all for humour and laughing at ourselves but South West Trains new campaign just comes across as mean-spirited and uniformed."

What do you think? Let us know in the comments.

Like this? Read these!


A founder member of the Creative Bloq team, Sammy Maine is now a freelance journalist. She also thinks that Buffy the Vampire Slayer is probably the best television series ever created.