Gillette has provoked an online backlash with a new advert that dares to suggest that traditional boorish male behaviour might not be cool after all.
Released on Sunday, the #MeToo (opens in new tab)-inspired short film is called 'We Believe: The Best Men Can Be' – a smart play on Gillette's familiar tagline, 'The best a man can get'. It wastes no time in showing off the the worst that men can be, with a compilation of actions traditionally associated with toxic masculinity, before going on to showcase examples of how men can take action to be better people and set the right example for the next generation – through respect and inclusivity and by no longer justifying bad behaviour through language such as 'boys will be boys'.
The ad has inevitably resulted in a furious online response; the video on YouTube has attracted, at the time of writing, 41,000 likes and 262,000 dislikes, and over on Twitter there's a tidal wave of petulant men's rights activist types on the #Gillette (opens in new tab) hashtag promising to boycott Gillette forever for daring to ask them to be decent human beings.
This is the latest in a growing trend for adverts that challenge outdated views and dare to make a statement – although many of the controversial TV and print ads (opens in new tab) we've seen so far focus on the female side of things.
- 4 ads that tried to be cool, but failed (opens in new tab)
Of course it hasn't escaped people's attention that the ad was directed by a woman: it's the work of Kim Gehrig at Somesuch (opens in new tab), who previously directed the 2015 'This Girl Can' campaign for Sport England (watch it below). Online commenters have been quick to single her out and accuse her of destroying Gillette (and, naturally, accuse her of being a 'feminazi').
So why would Gillette go out of its way to provoke this sort of reaction? Gillette's not stupid; it will have known from the outset that exactly this sort of backlash would happen, it'll have done its research and come to the conclusion that the positives of this undeniably thoughtful and provocative campaign would greatly outweigh the negatives. And beyond the advert, Gillette is putting its money where its mouth is, with a commitment to donating $1 million per year to US non-profits dedicated to helping men be their best.
And while we're sure that some of the Gillette marketing team are keeping a nervous eye on the ever-rising tally of YouTube dislikes and Twitter rants, there has also been plenty of praise for the campaign.
@Gillette new advert by @KimGehrig @Somesuchandco challenging stereotypes of masculinity & interpreting strength in a different way. Of course its being attacked by @piersmorgan & usual mob. But watch for yourself. Yes it’s an ad but the message matters https://t.co/gQslPM3SVpJanuary 15, 2019
Today, all the men in Britain who insist that everyone else is snowflakey, over-sensitive and thin-skinned will be crying about an advert that is not scheduled to appear on British TV. Just a heads up. #GilletteJanuary 15, 2019
As much as purpose-driven brands have to be wary of fatigue, I see this and marvel at the great conversations that must've taken place around that table. Bravo, @Gillette! Bravo, Director Kim Gehrig! Bravo, @GreyNewYork ! https://t.co/HWfLumvW4sJanuary 14, 2019
Gillette: Men, could you please be the best versions of yourselves and care for yourself and others Men: I beg your pardonJanuary 15, 2019
Although let's not go overboard here; others have been a bit more circumspect in their reaction.
I don’t know, maybe it’s possible to think the message of that Gillette ad is right *and* that it’s opportunistic marketing shit because of the source.January 15, 2019
If @Gillette really want to make a change perhaps they could start by looking at their pink ‘Venus’ range for women that includes names like Passion and Embrace and costs more than the men’s ranges for the same thing. Thanks.January 15, 2019
- 40 traffic-stopping examples of billboard advertising (opens in new tab)
- How gender affects design (opens in new tab)
- 66 brilliant print adverts (opens in new tab)