Affinity Designer vs Adobe Illustrator

(Image credit: Future / Adobe / Serif)

Illustrator has been the industry standard for vector-based graphic design for almost as long as there’s been a graphic design industry. Adobe has had rivals in CorelDraw, Inkscape and Sketch (see our guide to the best graphic design software for more details), but none have quite nudged them from their default position as top dog. But how does new(er) kid on the block Affinity Designer fare against this industry veteran?

We’re here to put Illustrator and Affinity Designer through their paces, investigate their differences and uncover their weaknesses to decide which is the better option for seasoned pros and early-career designers.

While both programs perform the same basic functions, making crossing between them relatively easy, one of the major ways they differ is in their pricing structure. Affinity Designer grants a perpetual licence for a single payment of $54.99 / £47.99, whereas Adobe switched to a subscription model in 2012, meaning that to use Illustrator a subscription of either $20.99 / £19.97 monthly (for Illustrator as a standalone) or $52.99 / £49.94 (for the Adobe Creative Suite) is required.

In terms of user interface, both Illustrator and Affinity Designer use a layout that’s pretty standard across graphic design programs, with the key toolbar on the left, the image window in the centre and specialised tool windows on the right. While there are differences in the tool graphics, they’re similar enough that a user migrating from one program to the other should be able to use either without much of an issue.

Both programs have the ability to customise their toolbar, meaning you can be rid of the tools you don’t use and prioritise the ones you use the most, and both have the ability to make simultaneous changes across all instances of similar objects; in Illustrator, this is called Global Editing, whereas in Affinity Designer you can designate an object, such as a logo, as a Symbol, giving you the opportunity to automatically copy across any changes made to all instances of it.

Illustrator has a lot of additional features that are text based, and considering the importance of text in graphic design, for many this will be the match point. Illustrator is integrated with Adobe Fonts, allowing users to preview Adobe fonts in situ before downloading them, and in the program itself, Illustrator possesses text editing abilities that Affinity Designer simply doesn’t have. One of the key elements is Illustrator’s Envelope Distortion tool, allowing text to be twisted and skewed intelligently to fit specific spaces.

One of the features where Affinity Designer wins over Illustrator, however, is in its grid functions. While Illustrator possesses the basics (horizontal, vertical, and… that’s it) Affinity Designer has a far wider range of tools, including an isometric tool, which along with a 'fit to plane' process, makes the creation of 3D shapes and patterns far, far easier. There are grid plugins available for Illustrator, but these add an extra cost to an already pricey piece of software.

One key element missing from Affinity Designer is a vector tracing tool. Crucial to some and utterly useless to others, there are several who will miss it if they switch. Adobe’s gradient tools are also far more advanced, with Mesh Gradient allowing for complex gradients with very little effort. In recent updates, Illustrator has also brought in a whole host of new 3D tools, including the ability to apply 3D effects to vector artwork and the ability to map vector artwork over 3D objects.

Illustrator is definitely the winner when it comes to compatibility. The global standard for vector illustration is AI, Adobe’s base format. Affinity Designer only saves in its own format – .afdesign – which has extremely limited compatibility with other programs. It can export files to a wide range of formats, but the risk in exporting to other formats is always that elements may be lost in translation, so that exported .AI files from Affinity Designer may arrive at the printer with missing or altered layers, making proofs even more important than normal.

Both programs use similar shortcut keys, with the option to modify them to suit your preferences, which makes transitioning between programs relatively simple. On the negative side, however, Affinity Designer lacks plugins, of which Illustrator has hundreds, ranging from map-rendering to packaging design. Affinity Designer also doesn’t have scripting functionality, meaning that manual input may be a more arduous task than for users of Illustrator.

As with most graphic design programs, both Affinity Designer and Illustrator are feature heavy, and given the wide variety of work that vector programs are used for, it’s unlikely that many users will use more than a handful of the special features that each has to offer. For anyone starting out, there’s a wealth of information and tutorials online covering all levels, from vector basics to more advanced graphic design elements. Start here with our roundup of Illustrator tutorials.

The two biggest things that Affinity Designer has going for it is the fact that it’s more intuitive than Illustrator, making it easier to learn for beginners or new users, and has far lower RAM requirements, making it easier to run on lower-powered computers and earlier generations of iPad. It’s therefore a far smaller investment for hobbyists or for graphic designers early on in their careers.

Affinity Designer’s ‘Designer’ Persona is your classic vector program, allowing you to draw curves and shapes, add vector brush strokes, manage fills and transparencies, add text and crop photos. The ‘Pixel’ Persona is a kind of Photoshop-lite, where users can make rasterised brush strokes and erase using raster erasers. These edits are made on adjustment layers, meaning that changes made can be switched on and off at will.

Illustrator can be bought either individually for a $20.99 / £19.97 monthly subscription or as part of the Adobe Cloud subscription (containing the whole Adobe Creative suite) for $52.99 / £49.94 per month (or $19.99 / £16.24 per month for students). This puts it out of reach for many smaller businesses or individual creators, or creatives in early stages of their career. The main positive to the subscription model, however, is that the software is always up to date, and purchasing new versions isn’t necessary. Illustrator has also constantly added new features with every update, making each version better value for money.

For professionals, there is only really one option; Illustrator is still the best in the business. Despite the higher cost, Illustrator in combination with the Adobe Creative Suite is the heaviest hitter, providing the most compatibility. Pedigree is one of its main advantages; the fact that .AI is so widely used across-platform makes it a key piece of software for any graphic designer working with vectors on high-budget projects.

Thank you for reading 5 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access

Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1

*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription

Join now for unlimited access

Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1

TOPICS

Affinity Designer vs Adobe Illustrator

Affinity Designer vs Illustrator: features and tools

Affinity Designer vs Illustrator: compatibility

Affinity Designer vs Illustrator: learning curve and usability

Affinity Designer vs Illustrator: flexibility

Affinity Designer vs Illustrator: system requirements

Affinity Designer vs Illustrator: price

Affinity Designer vs Illustrator: conclusion

What are the system requirements for Affinity Designer?

What are the system requirements for Illustrator?

Related articles